« The Right to Link | Main | Worky Worky Busy Bee »

January 22, 2007

Wikipedia Shouldn't Follow Nofollow

The SEO Blogs are all abuzz about Wikipedia applying the "nofollow" tag to all outbound links so Google doesn't index potential wikispam.

At Jimbo Wales' directive, all external links within the English language Wikipedia are now coded "nofollow" -- this should help cut spamming immensely once word gets out in the SEO community.

This was mentioned in the discussion Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard#Globalwarming awareness2007/SEO world championship -- expect a spam onslaught.

I haven't spoken with Jimmy about this, but I think this is the wrong decision.  As blogged previously, nofollow is a partial fit for blog comments, but not wikis:

I should mention that the wiki world isn't wild about nofollow for at least one simple reason. On a blog you have an author and the audience (commentators?).  Within a wiki, everyone is an author.  We are still evaluating where we will use nofollow, I personally see it as  great industry cooperation creating a tool to use.

Unfortunately this is throwing the baby out with the spamwater.  We need an alternative to this broad stroke.  Wikipedia is perhaps the best source of outbound links on the web, with a no-spam policy that while expensive to implement, largely works.  I'm concerned about how this effects the health of the web, search result and what precedent it sets for indexing public wikis as a whole.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341cd8a453ef00d83432f01953ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Wikipedia Shouldn't Follow Nofollow:

» If Wiki NoFollow The Terrorists Win from The Commerce360 Blog
Links built the internet. It was the ability to connect two pages or sites with just a link that separated the web from all that came before it. It was the inferred value of that link that created Google. Today... [Read More]

Comments

Feeds


  • TwitterCounter for @ross

Twitter @Ross

    follow me on Twitter

    Flickr


    • www.flickr.com

    Ligit

    About


    • Ross Mayfield is the Chairman, President & Co-founder of Socialtext, the first wiki company and leading provider of Enterprise 2.0 solutions,
    My Photo

    The 150



    • View Ross Mayfield's profile on LinkedIn

    Blog powered by TypePad
    Member since 08/2003