« Josh and danah at M2M | Main | Wiki Interview »

April 07, 2004

Industry Analyst Weblogs

Every time I hear of a new Industry Analyst blog I get all excited. Wicked smart people with great information flow that should have lots to say. Unfortunately, most Industry Analysts don't get blogging and the result is crap.

A bizzare standard has emerged where major firms simply repurpose abstracts in RSS format and call it a blog. The result is posts like this for Burton. Forrester takes the same approach and since nobody links to propoganda you can't even find it with Google. These don't even qualify as abstracts, they certainly aren't conversations and could be a form of spam.

What really works is letting analysts have their own voices, like Mike Gotta at Meta Group or the Jupiter blogs. Gartner is getting closer and started out with the bizzare.

Three suggestions for Industry Analyst firms:


  • Let analysts blog in their own voice with their own identity
  • Encourage them to blog the process of their research. All those interviews that never make it to print, readings and testable theories that result in good analysis.
  • If you are providing incentives for being quoted in the press, provide incentives for being linked

Of course, aside from firms, you will find the very best from independents like Amy Wohl and Stowe Boyd. Nothing holds them back, they engage as writers and readers and their practice benefits.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341cd8a453ef00d83457453e69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Industry Analyst Weblogs:

» And the number one Enterprise Portal is... from A Day in the Life of an Enterprise Architect: Thought Leadership
Figuring out who the number one portal vendor is becomes easy. Simply ask your favorite industry analyst. However, the answer they give you may not be accurate. Here's why?... [Read More]

Comments

Feeds


  • TwitterCounter for @ross

Twitter @Ross

    follow me on Twitter

    Flickr


    • www.flickr.com

    Ligit

    About


    • Ross Mayfield is the Chairman, President & Co-founder of Socialtext, the first wiki company and leading provider of Enterprise 2.0 solutions,
    My Photo

    The 150



    • View Ross Mayfield's profile on LinkedIn

    Blog powered by TypePad
    Member since 08/2003